Did god know that adam would sin jw Thus, from God’s standpoint, Adam TO KNOW why God made man, turn to the Bible, because therein God gives the answer. 30 - The Watchtower—1987 JW. Under inspiration the apostle Paul, writing to the Philippians, said: “Keep working out your own salvation with fear and trembling, for God is the one that, for the sake of his good pleasure, is acting within you in order for you both to will and to act. That gift is not at all in conflict with the fact that Adam was perfect. This question has perplexed many believers over the centuries, as it seems to chal Fun fact: Mormons don't believe that what Adam and Eve did was wrong. E. Our common ancestor Adam burdened all his descendants with sin. One is if God knew everything and if He knew that Adam and Eve might sin or would sin, why did He make them. One of the angels rebelled against God. for God is greater than our heart and knows all things. As a consequence of rebelling against Jehovah, they died Things did not immediately work out as Jehovah purposed. God gave humanity free will, knowing this meant the possibility of rebellion. By Noah’s day, the earth was full of violence, and the majority of Adam’s descendants chose to follow their progenitor’s wayward example. ” (Genesis 3:19) Think of what that means. He knew that both the man and the woman He created would disobey Above all, had God done nothing about the sin committed in Eden, his own trustworthiness would have been called into question. Not long after God created Adam and Eve, How were Adam and Eve to obey that command without having sexual relations? Are we really to suppose that God gave them a command and then sentenced them to death for trying to obey God is interested in relationships with us. Also why did God create them with the capacity to sin in the first place and then put test them with the tree of knowledge very well knowing that things could go south. 1 John 3:20 (NASB) The Greek says God “knows all. Because of what Adam did, “sin entered into the world and death through sin, and so death spread to all men because they had all sinned. (Luke 5:17-26) Hence, just as sin produced physical effects on mankind, the forgiveness of sins can result in benefits. If God Knew That Adam And Eve Would Sin, Why Did He Create Them? If God knew that Adam and Eve would sin, why did He create them? Why didn’t God prevent Adam and Eve from sinning?https://www. " At that time, Adam and Eve were both physically perfect and spiritually pure. But Eve believed it. 32:4. 119:142) Thus, having free will Jehovah gave Adam an important rule. (Genesis 2:17) When he became a sinner because of his disobedience, he became defective, imperfect. T. ") However, he was also created with free will, and with the ability to choose a course of action. Adam fully knew the penalty and so did Eve. Why did Adam die, and why do we, his offspring, also die? 19 When Adam sinned, he lost the right to everlasting life for himself and for all of his yet unborn offspring. He told Adam: ‘You can eat fruit from all the trees except for one special tree. Adam and Eve were not ignorant of God’s boundaries. ” (1 Peter 1:20; footnote) Did Jehovah predetermine from the beginning that Adam and Eve would sin and that the ransom So God’s restriction regarding this fruit was the only thing that made eating of it bad. ( Genesis 3:16 ) He was simply foretelling the sad consequences of sin on the first couple. ”Job 37:16; Psalm 139:2–4, 147:5; Proverbs 5:21; Isaiah God wisely gave them freedom, but Adam and Eve abused it. Second Peter 2:4 shows that some of God’s spirit sons did sin, being “delivered [into] pits of dense darkness to be reserved for judgment. Just think: By his sin, Adam caused the entire human race to be born as sinners. When God created Adam, did he know that Adam would sin? Here is what God set before Adam and Eve: “Be fruitful and become many and fill the earth and subdue it, and have in subjection the fish of the sea and the flying creatures of the heavens and every living creature that is moving upon the earth. . While not being dogmatic, C. First, by deception, Yes, God knew Adam and Eve would sin before he created them. But it’s true, God knew before He created man that man would sin. (Genesis 3:1-3) She repeated it to Satan, who was speaking through a serpent. ” (The normal thing, therefore, was for Adam to reflect God’s holy qualities, to respond appreciatively to God’s direction. Why should all humans suffer forever because of the sin of Adam and Eve? Megan: You’re right —it doesn’t seem fair. What they did was wrong —it was a sin. Likewise the product of God’s activity, the first human pair were also perfect. Adam and Eve became the first family. —Proverbs 1:5. Then God said: “Here the man has become like one of us in knowing good and bad, and now in order that he may not put his hand out and actually take fruit also from the tree of Perfect people are supposed to have perfect judgement and reasoning skills. God's intention is His glorification. Adam did rebel, and when he did, he became a sinner. In fact, if you eat from it, you will be like God. Yet, He valued our relationship with Him so highly that He allowed 5. His greed moved him to steal money that "This concise article seeks to provide a thoughtful response to a profound and enduring question: why did God create Adam and Eve, knowing they would eventually sin? Through a careful examination of Scripture, the author offers a nuanced exploration of God's purposes in creation, the nature of human freedom, and the ultimate display of God's glory. Eve listened to the serpent and ate of the fruit. 19. Andrew’s feedback is indented and in red. 6 pp. How has Adam and Eve’s decision affected us? Abel was born near the dawn of human history. —126 years after Adam’s death. Failing to trust their loving Father, they sinned. The human named Adam was from the earth, and returned there. 11 Sadly, Adam and Eve chose to disobey Jehovah. An invisible spirit, one who had no love for God or for them, entered the picture and tempted them to commit that sin. ” —Genesis 1:29; 2:17. In truth, only God is perfect in the absolute sense. As long as Adam —and his future offspring— remained obedient to God’s command, they would have no He lost his special friendship with Jehovah, his perfect life, and his Paradise home. The Issue of Universal Sovereignty 3-5. ” They are referencing Genesis 1:27 where God explains that he made It doesn't follow that there was a literal or history play of Adam and Eve "sin and thus fall from perfection" as Jehovah's Witnesses teach. When he sinned, God told him: “You [will] return to the ground, for out of it you were taken. Because Adam and Eve were perfect, it was natural for them to do what is right. 65-80 - “Eternal Purpose” (po) they rebelled against God, thus coming into captivity to sin, imperfection, and death. (Genesis 3:17-19) Adam and Eve chose to disobey God, so there was no hope for them. 6. God wasn't surprised by the Fall. ” (Genesis 3:6) They both disobeyed God. So it was not necessary for thousands of millions of individual humans to die sacrificial deaths to correspond to each Almost all independent chronologists assume incorrectly that, as soon as Adam was created, then began Jehovah’s seventh seven-thousand-year period of the creative week. “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. But God is God, who knew the heart and minds of every creation he formed. ’ (Exodus 9:16) Jehovah did make his name known. Not much in the Torah is narrative Now the fact that the true God knew that Adam would sin, means that God had allowed Satan to set him a task that was impossible for him at that time, namely, to desert his When the issue of God’s permission of wickedness is raised, the sin of the first human pair in the garden of Eden quickly comes into focus. I’ve heard pastors say, “God wanted a family, so he created Adam and Eve. How did Adam feel about his new wife? Adam was so happy that he said: ‘Look at what Jehovah made from my rib! At last! So, what did God say would happen if Adam ate the forbidden fruit? Alejandro: He said that Adam would die. Eve, however, chose to believe the one who spoke through the serpent instead of believing God, and Adam chose to listen to his wife who said, ‘Eat!’ instead of to Jehovah God, who had said, ‘Do not eat!’ Because Adam deliberately and with full Any bad action, feeling, or thought is a sin. ’ Later Jehovah said: ‘I am going to make a helper for Adam. Isaiah describes the breadth of God’s knowledge, saying that He knows “the end from the beginning and from ancient times things which have not been done” (Is. With this “free will,” they chose to sin. To fall short of this was to miss the mark, to sin. So, we are not found guilty by God for what Adam and Eve did. But there is more to it than that. Perfection did not rule out the exercise of free will to disobey. (Genesis 2:15-17; 3:6) Adam acted in a way that was contrary to God’s will, fell short of perfection, and marred his relationship with God. Satan did not die then, although he will eventually because he sinned. “In Adam all are dying,” says 1 Corinthians 15:22. God knew before Creating Adam and Even that they would sin. , why, six thousand years of God’s rest day would be ending in the fall of 1976. Man was created as an intelligent creature with the desire Some enemies criticized him for that. So Jesus proved it by healing a paralyzed man. Before The man needed no modern scientific radio receiver to hear the divine voice. ” Yes, “the tree of the knowledge of good and bad” symbolized God’s prerogative to set the standards for man as to what is approved or what is condemned. But Jehovah is faithful to his own standards; he never violates them. 3. The snake said: ‘You will not die. This one restriction caused no hardship; Adam and Eve could eat from all the other trees in the garden. If he was not there, they would not have sinned. What qualities of God rule out predestination? —Psalm 37:28; 1 John 4:8. —Genesis, chapter 3. Jesus later associated Abel with “the founding of the world. He knows, even now, the sins you will commit tomorrow because He is omniscient. God created Adam knowing he could sin and left it up to him to choose whether he would or not. 32:4) It was not God’s will for Adam to sin; he warned Adam against it. Thus, we sometimes do bad things and may later regret what we did. Genesis 3:6, 23. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. The very design of Creation itself reveals that God anticipated sin. ’ He made Adam fall into a deep sleep, and then God used one of Adam’s ribs to create a wife for Adam. Why did not God just destroy Adam and Eve and start over? 3 Why did God not just destroy Adam and Eve and start over with another human pair? Because his universal sovereignty, that is, his inalienable right to rule, had No intelligent theologian or religious scholar takes the story of Adam and Eve literally, but this does raise an important question, abstracted from the context of the Biblical story: why does God create human beings with the possibility of sin? There are a number of answers to this problem, so I would recommend looking into scholarship on the problem of evil. Army God created humans in His own image to have a unique fellowship with Him. ” Later, Adam “began eating it. ” (Genesis 3:19) God had made Adam from the dust of the ground. —Genesis 3:16-19. ” The Bible describes sin and death as “the shroud that is enveloping all the peoples and the covering that is In doing this, God surprised Adam with something that he did not know before, neither he nor his wife, Eve; namely, that in the middle of the garden there was the “tree of life” and that to be privileged to eat of that tree betokened that the eater was Certainly that was not too difficult a test. Meantime, however, he is alive and continues to mislead mankind. —Genesis 3:4, 5. Thus, He definitely knew that Adam and Eve would sin. This prohibition emphasized man’s proper dependence on God as his Sovereign Why didn’t God prevent Adam and Eve from eating the apple if he knew they’d cause mass destruction and violence and chaos? I already know the answer is “he can’t intervene” but shouldn’t he intervene in this case? in knowing that sin was going to happen, He allowed it to occur and did not either stop it or start over; this Tim Maas Supporter Retired Quality Assurance Specialist with the U. The tree was therefore a fitting symbol of the right to determine or set the standards of good and bad, which right God reserved for Himself by forbidding Adam to eat thereof. She did die and so did Adam. The Great Tempter, a fallen angel of the invisible heavens, was the one who prevailed upon Adam to sin. (1 John 3:4) And the penalty for sin is death, as God told Adam. ”—Genesis 3:1-5. But ask me why God created mankind even though He knew man would sin, and I hesitate. ” After God created the first man and woman, Adam and Eve, He put them in that lovely home and told them: “Be fruitful and become many, fill the earth and subdue it. . However, God Did Adam And Eve Cause Original Sin Did God Know That Adam And Eve Would Sin Did God Know That Adam Would Sin Did God Know That Adam Would Sin Catholic Did God Know That Adam Would Sin JW If God Knew That Adam And Eve Would Sin Why Did He Create Them Is It Blasphemous To Think God Knew Adam And Eve Would Sin What Was God's That basically God lets you sin. The Bible just reads to me that God purposely created us with a free will so we could choose Him or not and even though He could peek ahead, He mostly waits In Genesis 1:28, after God made Adam and Eve, He told them to "Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth and subdue it, and have dominion over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the heavens and over every living thing that moves on the earth. All of us 4. Furthermore, the world could never know God’s mercy or grace without the In view of the foregoing examples of sins that God forgave and those that he did not, the sincerely repentant Christian can come to God and plead with confidence for forgiveness, and that for a number of sound Scriptural reasons: He can plead on the basis of inherited sin even as did David: “Look! . —Genesis 3:1-5. Above all, had God done nothing about the sin committed in Eden, his own trustworthiness would have been called into question. But if you lived that stereotypical life of at least trying to not sin. ” He lost his special friendship with Jehovah, his perfect life, and his Paradise home. What happened to the first man, Adam, at his death? 2 To answer such questions, it will be a help for us to know what happened to Adam at his death. When he committed sin by breaking divine law, he began to die. C. That decision caused them great suffering. declaring the end from the beginning What promise did God make after Adam and Eve sinned? But we know that it started sometime after Adam’s wife, Eve, was created about 6,000 years ago. The first couple’s life was completely free from worries about food, work, sickness, and death. But the way that God corrected David teaches us about Jehovah’s forgiveness. From that time on, Adam’s body became Gen. (a) Why did Eve disobey God? (b) What did it mean to eat from the forbidden tree? 6 Eve disobeyed God and ate. However, the common teaching that we are guilty of the sin of Adam, known as Original Sin, is definitely not biblical. Adam and Eve gave in to that bad influence. Did God decide ahead of time that Adam and Eve would sin? —Genesis 1:28; 2:16, 17. ” (Genesis 1:1) With that simple, majestic sentence, the Bible introduces us to the Person who is the central figure throughout the Holy Scriptures —the almighty God, Jehovah. ” (Luke 11:50, 51) Jesus evidently meant the world of people who have the hope of being redeemed from According to the Bible, all humans are sinners. 1 John 3:2 says,. They did not pass on to the spirit realm. Because of what Adam did, “sin entered into the world and Genesis 3 says that Adam and Eve didn’t know good and evil before they sinned. How, then, could they sin? We know what happened. JW. What Jesus did on earth shows that God can bring an end to sickness and dying. 1:27: “God proceeded to create the man [Adam] in his image, in God’s image he created him. ” “Death ruled as king from Adam down. Adam and Eve were free to enjoy life as part of God’s universal family, as long as they respected their Creator’s standards of good and bad. But by willfully disobeying God, they sinned and rejected his rulership. That was a lie. ” “And Jehovah God also laid this Tim Maas Supporter Retired Quality Assurance Specialist with the U. You’re good. ” He knows everything from the past, the present, and the future. He It was God's divine decree that Adam and Eve would Fall. I know the pat answer. Not only did god know that Adam and Eve would fail the fruit test leading to the endless suffering of human kind, god knowingly set up Adam Beginning with his first overt act in turning Adam and Eve away from God, he was a manslayer, for he thereby brought about the death of Adam and Eve, which, in turn, brought sin and death to their offspring. 5:12, 14 ) Now, instead of being able to enjoy perfect, endless life as God had originally intended, humans are doing well if they live “70 years, or (I know God's ways are above our ways and He is God and I am not) The same would apply to the story of God's conversation with Satan regarding Job. In fact, “death ruled as king . By listening to him, you will become truly wise. The thousand years of Christ’s reign will soon begin, and during this time God will fulfill his purpose for the earth. (Genesis 2:16, 17; 5:5) Adam passed on to all his descendants sin and its No. It said slanderously that Jehovah God was a liar, not all-powerful, not able to enforce the penalty for the violation of his law. God didn't force them to sin, but God did preordain the Fall. What serious sins did David commit? 3 Although David was a man who wanted to obey God, he did commit serious sins. They were created perfect in mind and in body. He had to give them free will, because that was the only way that they could voluntarily choose to love and follow Him, which, in turn, was the only condition under which real love could exist. If you eat fruit from that tree, you will die. How did God accomplish that? “The wages sin pays is death,” says the Bible at Romans 6:23. , even over those who had not sinned in the same way that Adam transgressed. Two of these sins involved a married couple, Uriah and Bath-sheba. THEY have been called the most famous opening words ever written. Even though Adam’s life did not end until centuries later, he began to die from the day he disobeyed God. Adam sinned, so he died. They did not think that he was the God of the whole earth. If you do a Google search asking the question "what does the Bible say about God being all-knowing", you will see in the list of verses that come up that none of them suggest that God is all-knowing in the literal sense. If Adam had not sinned, he would never have died. Genesis 2:16–17). —Isaiah 46:9-11; 55:11. Satan had allowed his desire for power and independence to grow. God said: “You [will] return to the ground, for out of it you were taken. And God does everything for His own glory, including creating a world that He knows will fall into sin. This is a two-part question. God created Adam first, and then He created Eve out of Adam’s rib (Genesis 2:4-2:22). The first sin was an attack on God’s sovereignty. But God is sovereign which means he defined exactly what free will God did not create the devil knowing what he was going to do as God gave All his creation Free Will The devil was made very beautiful and very intelligent. Had He not done that we’d all worship Him like mindless drones, but because He gives us the choice He is just. The first part is “Did God know Satan would rebel?” We know from Scripture that God is omniscient, which literally means “all-knowing. docx Created Date: And he sinned, raised against God and since was immortal a power that god promised not to be withholding from them, created his own empire never to respect him! And sure, he also decided that he will misguide any creation God formed later on by disguising them. The thought that ‘God knows everything’ may easily Adam and Eve. God conversed with him directly. Her name was Eve. ( 1 Corinthians 15:45, 47 ) Thus Jesus’ entire faithful life course —including his sacrificial death— served as “one act of justification. For dust you are and to dust you will return. To take the name of the forbidden Although he confirmed the death penalty and the effects of sin began immediately, he allowed Adam and Eve to produce children who could benefit from other provisions that He would make. 37:28; Deut. ” Although Methuselah was the eighth in the line counted from Adam, did he know Adam his first human parent? po chap. So, what did God say would happen if Adam ate the forbidden fruit? Alejandro: He said that Adam would die. She ate the fruit and gave some to Adam. Sins by Angels. Yet before he sinned, God not only gave Adam authority to choose names for the birds and the beasts, but organised their (Revelation 12:9; Genesis 3:14) When God said that Adam would “dominate” his wife, God was not indicating his approval of the subjugation of woman by man. God’s Son, Jesus Christ, paid for our sins by God created Adam and Eve perfect, with the prospect of living forever in Paradise. The bigger picture is that God made Adam in his own image and desired fellowship with him. So he used a serpent to tell Eve that if she ate the fruit from that tree, she would not die, but she would be like God. ” Genesis 2:16-17 NIV “but God did say, ‘You must not eat fruit from the tree that is in the middle of the garden, and you must not touch it, or you will die Bible chronology places Noah’s birth in 2970 B. ” What did the serpent now say, and thus what did it accuse Adam and God of being? 23 Now, though, the serpent (or the one invisibly behind it) told Eve that her husband was a false prophet. So He definitely knew that Adam and Eve would sin. I agree with the observation that God knew Adam would sin and show more loyalty to his subordinate than the One he owed his very existence to – and with whom he conversed regularly and Its nature and circumstances. They grew old and died. When the issue of God’s permission of wickedness is raised, the sin of the first human pair in the garden of Eden quickly comes into focus. ” (Romans 5:12) When Adam sinned, he 2. (Genesis 2:7) Before Only if he rebelled against God would Adam lose that marvelous prospect. He is still a liar, and he tries to get people to break God’s laws. In knowing of the eventual abuse of his maximal self-gift through sin, God either gives all that can be given and does exactly as he would have done as if he did not know that there would be an abuse of the gift, or he holds back his generosity in order to prevent the abuse from happening by giving something less than the total gift which he 10 Speaking about the role that Jesus played in God’s purpose, the apostle Peter wrote: “He [Jesus] was foreknown before the founding of the world, but he was made manifest at the end of the times for the sake of you. Adam had been created perfect, sinless. (1 John 4:8) All his ways are just. But he doesn’t know if you will or not. By his action he brought man and woman under his Why did God create us knowing we would sin? He knew Adam and Eve would sin, but He created them anyway and gave them the ability to make decisions. Afterward, she gave some to Adam, and he ate it. God doesn’t know if you will or not. (Romans 14: 4, 12) He can forgive us even when our own heart still condemns us. If God knew Satan would successfully tempt Adam and Eve, why did God create humans with the ability to sin? Though the Bible does not explicitly answer this question, many principles can be seen. ” —Deut. That is why Jesus was a perfect man. As we know, Jehovah’s words proved true. First, God is the only perfect being. And His conversation with Job afterward. So by violating God’s command, Adam became a sinner. * And yet, even in this case, did God say anything about being punished in hellfire? Alejandro: No. To sin means basically “to miss the mark. “Then the LORD God said, ‘Behold, the man has become like one of Us, knowing good and evil; and now, he might stretch out his hand, and take also from the tree of life, and eat, and live forever’– (23) therefore the LORD God 11 This foreshadowed ransom had to be the exact equivalent of Adam, since the death penalty that God justly applied to Adam resulted in the condemnation of the human race. However, the Bible teaches that we cannot always trust our feelings. God’s Purpose Unchanged. Adam and Eve thereby lost perfection and severed their relationship with the Source of life, Jehovah. What freedom did Adam and Eve enjoy? (See opening picture. [Blurb on page 13] Statistics show that people who take precautions suffer fewer fatal consequences How do we know that? God told the first man, Adam, that if he committed what the Bible calls sin, he would die. But how God created Adam and Eve perfect, with the prospect of living forever in Paradise. What has Satan achieved? By listening to Satan, Adam and Eve put themselves under Satan’s rule and severed their relationship with God. Those sins caused very sad results for David, Uriah, and Bath-sheba. ” (Genesis 3:5) Did Adam and Eve’s choice lead to more After Adam and Eve had sinned Jehovah passed judgment on them. We know this because of what Jehovah said to Adam after confronting him with his disobedience. What responsibility do you have? —Joshua 24:15. This means that death is the consequence of sin. in sin my mother conceived me. ’” (NIV) He told Eve that if she disobeyed God, she would not die. Mauricio: That’s right. Judaism and Catholicism/Eastern Orthodox Christianity, as well as mainstream Protestantism teach that this narrative is, in the words of The Didache Bible: "Not scientific or historical but rather a kind of prologue that uses Secondly Adam, for his part, did not know that his sin would lead to pain and suffering, all he knew was that he would die if he sinned (Gen 2:16,17). ” ( Ro 5:12, 14 ) But Jehovah in his wisdom and love provided a “second man,” “the In response, we would first point out that the Bible never says that Adam and Eve did not know right from wrong. Among the sins that Jehovah undoubtedly did not forgive were those of Adam and Eve. So in order to become “the last Adam” and cover that sin, Jesus had to make a mature, knowing choice to keep his integrity to Jehovah. However, by verbally passing the story of their fall into sin and God’s promise of a coming Savior, Adam and Eve did verbally confess the gospel implicitly. It is important to know that. So Jehovah told the king of Egypt: ‘I am going to make my name known in all the earth. 22. Therefore Adam &Eve ahould have known not to eat the fruit. 119:142) Thus, having free will did not entitle Adam and Eve to disregard God’s law. The Bible’s first verse reveals that God is the Creator of the vast Since God took Jesus’ life from heaven and put it inside the woman Mary, Jesus did not get any sin from Adam. They were tyrannical bullies, and the sin of their lustful fathers is likened to the perversions of Sodom and The question of why did God make Adam and Eve knowing they would sin has quite a simple answer: First of all, He gave them the choice between Good and Evil. God knew that man would sin, but by allowing it to happen He was able to show the redeemed What did Adam and Eve decide to do? 11, 12. The more Eve looked at the fruit, the more she wanted it. Knowing Jehovah and imitating him would have made their lives satisfying, for he is “the happy God. a And yet, even in this case, did God say anything about being punished in hellfire? Alejandro: No. He must have been deeply hurt when his first two As a result of getting to know the character of all God's creatures it became clear that none of them was "a suitable helper" resulting in the creation of Eve. For God is omniscient. —John 8:44. As God’s handiwork, the planet Earth must have been perfect. As hard as it is to imagine, even sin, in the final analysis, redounds to the glory of God. ORG; Log In; However, we know without a single doubt that God is Omniscient (Psalm 139:1–6), and He knows the future (Isaiah 46:10). Since God’s spirit sons are also to reflect God’s glory and bring praise to him, carrying out his will (Ps 148:1, 2; 103:20, 21), they can sin in the same basic sense as humans. Genesis 3 depicts the tragic moment when Adam and Eve chose to rebel in the Garden of Eden, marring God's original "very good" creation with the curse of sin So they stepped outside the God-ordained limits of free will. Megan: Well, God created Adam and Eve, and he was the one they sinned against when they disobeyed in the garden of Eden. Isaiah quoted a statement from the Lord to show us: “I am God, and there is none like me. ’ Was that true? No, it was a lie. Why is it that Achan's family were all judged when it was only Achan who sinned? God did not spare angels when they sinned, but sent them to Being free moral agents, Adam and Eve could choose to obey God or disobey him. In the meantime, man’s desire —his need— to know God and to have a relationship with him is manifest in his search for purpose. (a) According to John 3:16, what did God do to rescue humans from sin and death?(b) What question can we discuss with people? 14 Read John 3:16. Did Judas Iscariot commit an unforgivable sin? Yes, he did. Eve chose to listen to Satan when he promised: “Your eyes will be opened and you will be like God, knowing good and bad. As What Adam did —willfully disobeying or breaking God’s law— is sin. In fact, Genesis 3:2–3 is clear that they did understand the difference between right and wrong; Eve knew God had instructed her and Adam not to eat the forbidden fruit (cf. He told them how best to use their freedom and warned them of the consequences of disobeying: If they lived according to God’s instructions, they would enjoy perfect life forever; if they chose their Then perhaps add: (1) ‘Jehovah is a God of love. ” “Through one man sin entered into the world and death through sin, and thus death spread to all men because they had all sinned. He accused God of lying, and he told Eve that she and Adam would be better off deciding for themselves what was good and what was bad. ) 4 When reading the first two chapters of Genesis, we can easily see that Adam and Eve enjoyed the kind of freedom that people today can only hope for —freedom from want, from fear, and from oppression. Why? Eve believed Satan. 1:28. ’ He made Adam Caller: My question was about God knows everything, so why, in the first place, did He make Adam and Eve? Why did He test them? Pastor Doug: Ok you’ve asked two questions. We inherited the tendency to sin from the first man, Adam. Satan wants to bring all people under his own rule. 46:10). ” Did God speak through an angel, perhaps the Logos, who became Jesus? That is quite possible. —1 Timothy 6:17; Genesis 2:8, 9, 16, 17. THE Bible says of God: “Perfect is his activity. How could they be held morally responsible for sin without the knowledge of good and evil? The text in question is from Genesis 3:22, where, following Adam and Eve’s sin in the Garden of Eden, “the Lord God said, ‘The man has now become like one of Us, knowing good and evil. According to If Adam and Eve were perfect, why did they choose to sin? the serpent tricked Eve into eating the apple. Adam was warned, however, that “in the day you eat from [the tree of knowledge] you will positively die. Russell wrote: “Jesus perhaps was the Representative of God in the Garden of Eden with Adam. (As the verse cited in the question states, he was made "in the likeness of God. Adam and Eve did not obey God, so they died. In fact, they think it was a gift. Of course, that was a lie. at the time, apparently did not know the identity of the one misleading her. That includes such things as uncontrolled anger, cursing at one’s mate or children, nurturing a wrong desire, or giving in to a selfish impulse. gotquestions. Why did Adam and Eve’s choice lead to disaster? Give an example. It contains important information that God wants you to know. I don’t know. ” Adam truly did that. God required sin to exist so that He could demonstrate His wrath and justice. The thought that ‘God knows everything’ may easily lead some to the conclusion that God must have known beforehand It was possible for Adam to sin because God created him with free will. He was not so foolish as to God is omniscient (Psalm 139:1–6), and He knows the future (Isaiah 46:10). One of the most profound mysteries in Christianity is why God would create Adam and Eve, knowing full well that they would eventually sin and bring sin into the world. Romans 5:12 says: “Through one man [Adam] sin entered into the world and death through sin, and so death spread to all men because they had all sinned. So either the serpent or humans sinned because of free will. Satan did not want Adam and Eve to obey Jehovah. He gave Microsoft Word - Why did God Create Man Knowing He Would Sin. (Deuteronomy 32:4; 2 Samuel 22:31) When he disobeyed Jehovah’s basic => Thus, it is only reasonable to conclude that the all-wise God did not exercise his ability of foreknowledge to know in advance that our first parents would sin. By refusing to obey God’s law, man was calling into question God’s very right to Did God Know That Adam and Eve Would Sin? Why Learn From God? “He Softened the Face of Jehovah” Did You Know? Does God Really Care About You? He Endured Despite Disappointments An East Asian in Ancient Italy Appreciate Sacred Things! JW. (Jeremiah 17:9) God has not authorized us to judge anyone —even ourselves. She knew it so well that she was later able to repeat it almost word for word. ( Luke 1:30-35 ) That is also why an angel said to the shepherds when Jesus was born: “There was born to you today a Savior. Army Adam WAS created perfect. (Ps. God wants the earth to be a paradise where perfect humans can live “And the Lord God commanded the man, “You are free to eat from any tree in the garden; but you must not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, for when you eat from it you will certainly die. It was not a test. He did so to demonstrate His full character to us. That book is the Bible. Just as wise teachers test their students, God tested Adam and Eve in their obedience. When they rebelled against God, they sinned. ” (1 Timothy 1:11) As the God “who furnishes us all things richly for our enjoyment,” Jehovah put the first man in a paradise called the garden of Eden, with the prospect of living forever. It all seems like one big giant set up. It was not so man could have autonomy from God's intended purpose. ” Feedback archive → Feedback 2007. Such then figure that from Adam’s creation, now thought to be the fall of 4025 B. Life was hard for them and their children. The Bible shows that. Do you know how he did that?— But God knows everything. w87 1/1 p. But He created them anyway and gave them a It doesn't follow that there was a literal or history play of Adam and Eve "sin and thus fall from perfection" as Jehovah's Witnesses teach. Many of the people we invite to the Memorial know this verse by heart. ORG; Log In; Share In fact, he went on to tell Eve: “For God knows that in the very day of your eating from it your eyes are bound to be opened and you are bound to be like God, knowing good and bad. Did God know that Adam would sin before He created him? This week’s feedback is from ‘Andrew’ of South Australia, who did not agree with most of the points in a sermon by Russell Grigg which encapsulated many of the things Russell has written in various articles for Creation magazine. Answer: Through disobedience, Adam and Eve lost virtually everything that God had provided to them. Ezekiel 18 and Ezekiel 31 makes it quite clear that we will only be held accountable for our own sins, not for the sins of another person. Why, then, did God tell Adam and Eve to ‘subdue the earth’? —Gen. Since God is omniscient, He already knew Adam and Eve were going to sin. Yes, God made arrangements to redeem, or buy back, what Adam had lost for his descendants, namely, the prospect of endless life. 4. ’ (2) ‘God did allow Adam, as he does us, the freedom to choose what he would do. They would have stayed in the Garden of Eden forever and never had the chance to earn their place with God back in heaven, nor would they The Lord created Adam and Woman with the intent that sin would exist. Why did God create Adam knowing that Adam would disobey Him? Bible Answer: Yes, God created Adam knowing that he would disobey. But He created them anyway and gave them a free will with which they chose to sin. S. Let’s remember that God created a world that was perfect and a man who was sinless (Gen 1:31). The true God directed men to write down his thoughts in one sacred book. God knows what is best for us, and he is the Source of all wisdom. Later Jehovah said: ‘I am going to make a helper for Adam. When Moses went back to Egypt, the Egyptians thought that Jehovah was just a small god of the Israelites. Why did Adam and Eve disobey Jehovah? 5 Adam told Eve about Jehovah’s command. a Nevertheless, God’s original purpose for mankind will be fulfilled. ” ( Genesis 1:28; 2:8, 9, 15 ) So it was God’s purpose that humans have children, extend the boundaries of that garden home earth wide, and take care of the animals. God didn’t force Adam and Eve to sin, but from all eternity He knew it, He ordained it, and it was part of His glorious plan of redemption. org/if-God-knew-Ad Ask me who made God, why suffering is in the world, or why God allows evil, and I will answer you quicker than the government gives away our tax dollars. First, they were evicted from their garden home. As a test of their appreciation God gave them a simple command; they were not to eat of the fruit of a certain tree; and he warned them of the consequences if they did eat of it. God made them leave their Paradise home. Thus, even if Adam and Eve did not literally trust in Jesus, they still trusted in what God had revealed to them about the future provision of salvation. 14. This went to his head and he said he could rule over mankind better than God could himself, so he was sent down to prove it. Can I ask you a personal question? Caller: Yes. —1 John 3: 19, 20. A Fitting Restriction. That wicked angel is Satan the Devil. Did Adam plan his sin, or how did Adam come to sin, and that willfully? 22 Adam did not plan his sin. He put him in a perfect environment and gave him dominion over the creation. ORG ® / OFFICIAL Why did God allow Satan to be in the garden of Eden. ” ( Rom. (Deuteronomy 32:4; 2 Samuel 22:31) When he disobeyed Jehovah’s basic instructions, Adam became imperfect. kkae synwy lsoewh xer ovuhqkv yptco janwb eprdbh nyiim sdccdic